Hey — It’s Nico.

This is Behind Tactics 🧠, the Failory newsletter where I share the strategies behind the best startups.

In this issue:

• How Wayfair bootstrapped its way to $500M in annual revenue without any major funding.

• Why Wayfair used to be a collection of over 200 different sites, and how this strategy is responsible for their success.

• Why specialized niche sites rank so well on Google.

• How Wayfair’s divide-and-conquer strategy can be applied by any startup.

This issue is sponsored by Playbookz, the LinkedIn ghost-writing service used by Founders & CEOs.

Let’s get into it.

Get 100K+ LinkedIn Reach in 6 Months or We Work for Free ^AD

My friend Perrin has launched something new! Let me pitch it to you:

The Problem:

• For founders, building an online audience is crucial (I’ve written about this in the past).

• LinkedIn is the most powerful platform to do so.

• Being active on LinkedIn while building a startup is hard.

The Solution:

• Playbookz is a social ghostwriting service that helps founders/CEOs build profitable personal brands on LinkedIn.

• They write the content based on your experience and get people in your industry to engage with it.

• You get leads, deals and relationships.

The Offer:

• For being a Failory friend, you get $1,000 off in your first month.

• Additionally, if in the first 6 months you don’t get 100K+ reach, they work for free.

The Strategy

One Product, One eCommerce

Wayfair is now one of the largest companies in online furniture retail, selling pretty much anything related to furniture or house appliances.

However, before becoming the e-commerce giant we know today, Wayfair had a very different business model. 

When the company launched in 2002, Wayfair, then called CSN Stores, operated a network of over 200 niche websites, each dedicated to a specific category of furniture and home goods. This network included websites like strollers.com, cookware.com, and everyatomicclock.com.

The founders of Wayfair realized that by dividing the furniture market and creating different sites that each specialized in a specific product, they could outperform their more generalist competitors.

This divide-and-conquer strategy allowed them to cater to specific customer needs, making each website a go-to place for particular products. 

By focusing on niche markets, Wayfair could engage with targeted audiences more effectively. Each site was designed to attract a specific set of customers looking for particular items. This not only improved customer satisfaction but also optimized their marketing efforts. 

For instance, one of their first sites, RacksandStands.com, sold TV and stereo stands. By specializing, they became the top choice for those products, dominating the search results and customer preferences in that category.

The results were impressive. Wayfair bootstrapped its way to $500M in annual revenue without any major funding.

Their niche websites allowed them to tap into different markets, minimizing customer acquisition costs (CAC) and maximizing customer lifetime value (LTV). They cross-promoted their websites, turning a visitor on one site into a potential customer on another.

However, the strategy wasn't without its challenges. By 2011, changes in Google’s search algorithm started affecting their traffic.

To adapt, they raised their first significant round of funding—$165M—and rebranded as Wayfair.

This consolidation took over a year to gain traction, but by 2014, Wayfair went public, raising $319M with a valuation of $3B.

Targeting the Long Tail

Wayfair's early success wasn't just about having multiple niche websites; it was also about how they optimized these sites for search engines.

Their strategy revolved around targeting long-tail keywords instead of trying to compete for the more generic ones.

Long-tail keywords are longer, more specific search phrases with less competition than broad, generic terms. For example, instead of targeting "furniture," Wayfair targeted phrases like "modern TV stands" or "wooden baby cribs." This made it easier for their niche websites to rank higher in search engine results, attracting customers who were looking for exactly what they offered.

By focusing on these specific keywords, Wayfair managed to attract a highly motivated audience. These visitors were not just browsing; they were looking for specific items, making them more likely to purchase.

This strategy not only improved their conversion rates but also lowered their customer acquisition costs. It’s much cheaper to attract customers who already have a clear idea of what they want than to convince a broad audience to buy something they might not need.

Moreover, Wayfair's extensive network of niche websites allowed them to dominate a wide range of search terms. Each new site they launched could be optimized for different sets of long-tail keywords, further expanding their reach.

The beauty of this approach was in its simplicity and scalability. Building a new niche site required relatively low investment but offered high returns in terms of SEO and customer acquisition. They launched a new website every 10.5 days.

As each site grew, Wayfair could cross-promote products across its network, increasing customer lifetime value and creating a loyal customer base.

Should I?

Why This Works

• SEO Benefits: By creating a separate website for each furniture category, Wayfair was able to build topical authority around each niche. This demonstrated to Google and other search engines their clear expertise in those fields, making it easier to rank higher in search results. Unlike generalist websites that sell a wide variety of products, Wayfair’s niche sites were perceived as more authoritative and relevant by search engines.

• Better Customer Experience: Each niche website was designed with a specific audience in mind, offering a curated selection of products and a more personalized shopping experience. This not only improved customer satisfaction but also increased the likelihood of repeat business, as customers found precisely what they were looking for without sifting through unrelated items.

• Scalable Growth: This strategy allowed them to launch into new markets slowly as they identified and validated opportunities. Suppose they had launched one single website from the beginning. In that case, they’d have needed to build an extensive catalog of products in all categories to compete with other sites selling furniture. By slowly creating new niche sites, they were able to bootstrap their way into dominating all categories.

How to Apply It

• Niche Down: Begin by identifying specific, targeted products or services that meet the needs of your target customers. Instead of trying to offer everything to everyone, focus on a particular niche where you can provide specialized expertise and value. For example, if you are starting an online store, consider focusing on a single category, like eco-friendly baby products or artisanal kitchen tools.

• Optimize for SEO: Concentrate your SEO efforts on long-tail keywords that are specific to your niche. Ensure your website is optimized with relevant keywords, meta descriptions, and high-quality content that addresses the needs and questions of your potential customers. Regularly update your site to keep it relevant and maintain its search engine ranking.

• Use Data: Leverage data analytics to gain insights into customer behavior and preferences. This will help you find new niches and understand which ones are worth focusing on.

• Scale Gradually: Test new ideas on a smaller scale before committing significant resources. This allows you to validate your concepts, minimize risks, and make adjustments based on real-world feedback.

Yes, But

• Takes a Lot of Resources: Managing multiple niche sites requires significantly more resources than maintaining a single, larger site. Each site needs its own content, SEO strategy, marketing efforts, and customer support. Additionally, ensuring each site remains up-to-date, functional, and relevant can be an ongoing challenge.

• Customer Loyalty Challenges: One major drawback of this strategy is the potential difficulty in building customer loyalty. Customers who visit different niche sites might not realize they are purchasing from the same parent company. This can make it harder to build brand recognition and trust. Customers might be less likely to return if they don't recognize the brand or understand its broader offering.

• Dependency on Google: Wayfair's growth relied heavily on SEO and search ads, making them vulnerable to changes in Google's algorithms. This dependency on a single marketing channel can be risky. When Google launched the Panda algorithm update in 2011, many of Wayfair's niche sites were adversely affected, leading to a significant drop in search engine rankings and traffic and forcing Wayfair to change its strategy altogether.

Keep Learning

Others Playing It

Quidsi

Quidsi is the closest case to Wayfair. They had multiple niche sites focused on different online shopping categories, like Diapers.com, Soap.com, BeautyBar.com, Wag.com, Casa.com, and Yoyo.com.

In 2010, Quidsi was acquired by Amazon for $545 million.

Diagram

Diagram.com has been following a similar strategy by building many different products that mix design and AI. Each of these products is its own separate tool and has its own site. Some of these tools include: 

• Automator: Which lets you automate Figma tasks.

• Magician: An AI image generator tool for Figma.

• Prototyper: Which lets you make interactive Figma designs using JS.

Refer Failory, Get Rewards

Share Failory

Chances are you have some more friends who would enjoy Failory as much as you do. Share Failory with these friends and cash in on premium resources and swag.

You currently have 0 referrals, only 1 away from receiving my Pitch Deck Airtable.

_{Or copy and paste this link to others: https://newsletter.failory.com/subscribe?ref=PLACEHOLDER}

Help Me Improve Failory

That’s all for this edition.

Cheers,

Nico