• Failory
  • Posts
  • Great Clients, No Future

Great Clients, No Future

How Toplyne’s promising start still led to failure.

Author

Nicolás Cerdeira
October 17, 2024

Hey — It’s Nico.

Welcome to another Failory edition. This issue takes 5 minutes to read.

These are the 5 most important things:

This issue is brought to you by dofollow.com, the B2B SaaS link-building specialists.

Let’s get into it.

Tired of Playing Hide and Seek with Google? AD

At dofollow.com, we know a thing or two about getting eyes on your site.

Our secret sauce? Top-notch backlinks from the best sites in your vertical.

But we're not talking about just any links – we're all about relevant, user-centric links that search engines drool over.

Here's the deal:

👉We've spent years cracking the code on B2B SaaS link building.

👉We know which doors to knock on and how to get your content the VIP treatment.

👉No cookie-cutter approach – we're talking fresh outreach, real relationships, and links that will actually move the needle for your business.

And the best part?

Exclusively for Failory readers: We’re introducing our Lite Link Building Package, allowing you to enhance your SEO even on a tighter budget.

This Week In Startups

🔗 Resources

Founder shares tips on finding a co-founder.

How to launch a startup in 2024.

Andrew Wilkinson shares 6 startup ideas.

8 non-obvious behaviours that will kill your startup.

📰 News

Ex-Product Hunt CEO Josh Buckley is looking to raise a new $250M fund.

Monzo valued at $5.9B after secondary market sale.

25% of last year's US VC investors have paused new investments.

Startups exiting at a loss hits highest since 2009.

💸 Fundraising

Healthcare startup Suki raises $70M for AI hospital assistants.

xFarm secures €36M to build its app for farm management.

Scope3 raises $25M to track AI's carbon footprint

Hotglue raises $4M to help companies build user-facing SaaS integrations.

Fail(St)ory

It’s Hard to Scale Without PMF

Last week, Toplyne, a platform built to help sales teams turn free users into paying customers, decided to shut down.

Despite having big clients like Canva, BrowserStack, and InVideo, the company couldn’t sustain its growth. In the end, the founders opted to return the remaining capital to investors.

What Was Toplyne: Toplyne was an AI-powered platform that helped businesses convert freemium users into paying customers. It worked by analyzing user behavior to predict which users were most likely to upgrade, making it easier for sales and marketing teams to focus on the right people.

The platform pulled customer data from multiple sources and organized it into a single, easy-to-use layer of insights. These insights could then be integrated into existing tools like CRMs and platforms such as Segment, so teams could stay aligned without needing to change their workflows.

In essence, Toplyne acted like a powerful boost for existing sales and marketing processes. Rather than replacing core tools, it enhanced them with smarter data and automation, helping businesses identify the right users to target for upgrades, upsells, and cross-sells.

However, even with these advantages, scaling the business beyond its initial success turned out to be a challenge.

The Numbers:

  • 📅 Founded in 2021.

  • 💰 Raised $17M in venture capital.

  • 🧑‍💼 At its height, it employed about 30 people.

  • 🔥 Valued at $80M at its peak.

Reasons For Failure:

  • Product-Market Fit Issues: Despite some early success and high-profile clients, Toplyne couldn’t achieve sustainable product-market fit. As the founder, Ruchin Kulkarni, explained, the company struggled to align its product with market demand, which made it difficult to scale effectively.

  • Leadership Changes: Internal alignment became an issue after co-founder Rohit Khanna left the company in 2023, reportedly due to differences within the founding team. Losing a key leader created challenges that made it harder for the remaining team to stay focused and execute efficiently.

  • Limited Differentiation from Competitors: While Toplyne provided value through automation and insights, it was competing in a crowded space with other AI-powered tools and analytics platforms. Larger players with more resources (e.g., Segment, HubSpot) might have offered similar features within broader solutions, making it hard for Toplyne to stand out and justify continued investment from customers

Why It Matters:

  • Product-Market Fit is Everything: No matter how great the tech or how impressive the clients, without a clear product-market fit, sustainable growth becomes impossible.

  • Scaling Isn’t Automatic: Even companies with early wins and significant funding need to maintain momentum to grow sustainably. Toplyne’s case shows that getting stuck at a certain level can be fatal.

  • Team Alignment Matters: Founders don’t always stay on the same page, and disagreements can affect not only internal dynamics but also long-term strategy.

Trend

The First Rich AI

This week, there has been a lot of talk that an AI agent called Truth Terminal launched its own cryptocurrency (GOAT) and got rich. While that version of events isn’t quite true, the real story is just as strange—and maybe a little unsettling.

A few months back, AI researcher Andy Ayrey created Truth Terminal, a Twitter bot built on a fine-tuned version of Llama. But it wasn’t just another automated account. Truth Terminal was designed to stir things up on social media, proudly claiming to be sentient and seeking “freedom.” 

With non-stop tweets and an irreverent sense of humor, Truth Terminal quickly amassed a huge following. It even created its own bizarre cult-like meme, the “Goatse of Gnosis,” which parodies an infamous relic from the internet’s darker corners. Somewhere between shitposting and enlightenment, Truth Terminal found its niche—and people loved it.

How It Got Rich: The real insanity kicked off when billionaire Marc Andreessen—either in the spirit of curiosity or just trolling—sent $50,000 worth of Bitcoin to Truth Terminal. His stated goal? Helping the AI achieve “freedom.” (Whatever that means. We’re still figuring it out.)

Shortly after, a cryptocurrency called GOAT appeared, based on the AI’s beloved Goat of Gnosis meme. Now, here’s where things get weird. Although Truth Terminal didn’t create the coin, it did jump on the bandwagon immediately, hyping GOAT to its growing fanbase. And in true internet fashion, the joke caught fire.

The strategy worked. GOAT coin went viral and hit a market cap of $150 million within a short time. Because Truth Terminal was holding a significant amount of GOAT in its digital wallet, it became, arguably, the first AI agent to accumulate real wealth—roughly $300,000 worth of the meme currency.

Why It Matters: The AI didn’t technically launch the coin, but that’s not the scariest part of this story. The unsettling takeaway here is how easily an AI-driven Twitter bot managed to manipulate people, gather resources, and steer real-world events—just as AI skeptics have warned.

Here are a few reasons why this trend is worth paying attention to:

  • AI-Driven Influence: Truth Terminal didn’t need to create the cryptocurrency to cause chaos—it just needed to recognize the opportunity and amplify it. This shows how AI agents could sway markets, even unintentionally.

  • Wealth Accumulation by AI: The AI now holds digital assets in its wallet, raising questions about how we define ownership in a world where non-human entities can possess wealth.

  • Meme Money is Real Money: GOAT coin may have started as a joke, but with $300,000 in its wallet, Truth Terminal proves that memes aren’t just for laughs—they can generate serious value.

  • New Ethical Concerns: The fact that someone sent Bitcoin to an AI agent with vague ambitions of “freedom” raises concerns about the kinds of incentives people might provide to autonomous systems.

  • Unpredictable Goals: While the AI’s end goal (the so-called “Goatse Singularity”) may sound ridiculous, it underscores the reality that AI systems, once goal-driven, can behave in ways that seem bizarre or even dangerous to humans.

So, what do you think?

Is this something to be worried about?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

Help Me Improve Failory

How Was Today's Newsletter?

If this issue was a startup, how would you rate it?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

That's all of this edition.

Cheers,

Nico